MEETING MINUTESMinutes Regular Meeting of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library Board of Trustees September 19, 2002 The regular monthly meeting of the Board of Trustees of the Buffalo and Erie County Public Library was held on Thursday, September 19, 2002, in the Central Library pursuant to due notice to trustees. The following members were present: Daniel T. Roach, Chairman; Annette A. Juncewicz, Secretary; James W. Burns, Treasurer; William P. Brosnahan; John B. Long; Rebecca L. Mahoney; Abdul H. Raoof, Ph.D.; Judith K. Summer; Sharon A. Thomas; Raul Vazquez; Wayne D. Wisbaum; Stanley H. Zagora; Robert J. Plache, Trustee Emeritus; George M. Zimmermann, Trustee Emeritus. Absent: Phyllis A. Horton, out of town; Elaine M. Panty, ill. Chairman Roach called the meeting to order at 4:05 p.m. in the Joseph B. Rounds Conference Room. Agenda Item B - Approval / Changes to the Agenda. The agenda was approved with the addition of Item J.2 - LSTA Summer Reading Program Grant. Agenda Item C - Minutes of the Meeting of August 15, 2002. On motion by Ms. Mahoney and seconded by Mr. Burns, the Minutes of the meeting of August 15, 2002 were approved as mailed. Agenda Item D - Report of the Chair. Mr. Roach conveyed the Board's best wishes to the Director's secretary who will retire on September 27th. Mr. Roach informed trustees that the Library Board's Foundation Review Committee met with the Foundation's Select Committee on September 10th to discuss merging the two groups to form a Projects Review Committee. This joint committee would analyze requests for funding and discuss with Library staff the benefits associated with the request. Subsequent to the Committee's endorsement, the project will be submitted to both Boards for their approval. The creation of the Projects Review Committee was unanimously approved at the September 10th meeting, subject to ratification by both Boards. On motion by Ms. Mahoney and seconded by Ms. Summer, B&ECPL Trustees ratified the Committee's action. Agenda Item E - Committee Reports. Agenda Item E.1 - Executive Committee. In the absence of Ms. Panty, Director Chrisman reported that the Executive Committee met on September 12th to prepare the agenda for today's meeting. Agenda Item E.2 - Budget & Finance Committee. Mr. Burns called on Deputy Director Kenneth Stone to present the report of the Budget & Finance Committee. Agenda Item E.2.a - 2003 Budget Approval. Mr. Stone informed the Board that the Library's 2003 budget request was submitted to the Erie County Budget Office on August 30, 2002. The Executive Committee approved the budget request at a special meeting on August 19th with the understanding that minor revisions be approved by the Chairman of the Board. The adopted resolution was transmitted to trustees in their Board packets. RESOLUTION 2002-54
Agenda Item E.2.b - Contract Library Transfers. On motion by Ms. Summer and seconded by Ms. Juncewicz, the following was approved unanimously: RESOLUTION 2002-55
RESOLUTION 2002-56
Agenda Item E.2.d - Amend State and County Corrections Grants. Mr. Stone explained that aid provided by State and County Corrections grants is based upon facility prison population. Often the actual prison populations vary from estimates used in preparing budgets. Resolution 2002-57 adjusts the actual prison population figures used in dispersing state aid and transfers funds between accounts to match the final service plan approved by the state. On motion by Ms. Summer and seconded by Dr. Raoof, the following was approved unanimously: RESOLUTION 2002-57
Agenda Item E.2.e - Amend 2002 Budget, County Legislature Member Aid Item - Town of Newstead. The allocation of $1,200 to benefit the Newstead Public Library was sponsored by Legislator Michael H. Ranzenhofer. On motion by Ms. Mahoney and seconded by Ms. Summer, the following was approved: RESOLUTION 2002-58
Agenda Item E.2.f - Monthly Financial Report. The monthly financial statement for the period ending July 31, 2002 was included in Board packets for information. Agenda Item F - Report of the Director. In addition to her written report, Ms. Chrisman noted that Library Trustee Wayne D. Wisbaum will chair the newly formed Projects Review Committee mentioned by Chairman Roach during his report. She indicated that Assistant Deputy Director Ruth Collins and Deputy Director Michael Mahaney were in attendance at the September 10th meeting to talk about renovations planned for the Central Library. B&ECPL Board members had approved a resolution in July authorizing the Library administration to take the steps necessary to advance the renovation, including a request to the Library Foundation to secure necessary private funds to implement the project. Mr. Wisbaum reported that Foundation Board members were very enthusiastic about the renovation and were unanimous in their support of a request that the Foundation undertake a $1 million fund-raising initiative for the renovation. Ms. Chrisman circulated pictures of the new landscaping at the Niagara Branch Library. Landscaping at the Mead Branch was completed last month. The following report was submitted by the Director and transmitted to Board members prior to the meeting: B&ECPL's e-Branch is Born: The Central Library's Remote Reference Center has been renamed the e-Branch to highlight the expanded coordinative role it plays in B&ECPL's technology services, from gathering feedback on electronic products for System purchase to functioning as the public service liaison to the Network Office. With the arrival of e-Branch, e-mail reference activity is expected to increase dramatically, so Webmaster Brian Fending has collaborated with Carol Batt and staff to redesign the website, making it more intuitive for patrons seeking online reference assistance. A link to AskUs appears on the Library's home page. A click away is an electronic form that can be completed and submitted for a response - in most cases - within 24 hours. The Technology Services Committee, chaired by Maureen McLaughlin (Catalog Department), originated the concept of e-Branch. Organizationally, e-Branch falls under the Office of System Public Services. Art on Wheels: The Central Library has been selected as a host site for "Art on Wheels: artists recycle, reuse, and reinvent in 2003." This community cultural tourism initiative will extend throughout the Buffalo Niagara Region from May through October 2003. The project will create an Arts Trail of art cars (automobiles transformed into art pieces) to be displayed with other wheel-themed sculptures at nearly 50 historic and heritage sites. At the media launch on August 28th, agencies had an opportunity to display pictures and information about their sites for review by potential sponsors. Library artist Dawn Stanton prepared a beautiful poster featuring the Mark Twain Room. The Central Library was the first site selected for sponsorship. 2003 County Budget Request: The Board's Executive Committee approved the 2003 budget request on August 19th, with final adjustments approved by the Board Chair on August 27th, and transmitted to the Erie County Budget Office on August 30th. Timing of the budget instruction release and the August 30th deadline did not provide sufficient time for preparation and board review of the budget request prior to the August 15th regular board meeting. Recently implemented major increases in employee health insurance costs and a significant anticipated increase in the employer share of New York State Retirement System costs added $1.1 million to the projected increase needed just to maintain existing services. Contractual cost of living adjustments and other operating changes increased this total to $1.8 million, making this one of the most challenging budget situations faced by the Library in several years. Participating in Erie County's implementation of the 2002 New York State Early Retirement Incentive Program for the first time since 1998 as well as closely reviewing revenue, expenditure and fund balance estimates reduced the anticipated funding increase needed from $1.8 million to $797,501. This amount has been requested in the form of an inter-fund subsidy. On September 5th, the Director attended a County Budget session to discuss the Library's plans for 2003. A County Executive's recommended budget is anticipated in late October to early November. City of Buffalo Capital Project Review Hearing: On September 4th, Deputy Directors Michael Mahaney and Ken Stone and the Director presented an overview of the City Branch Capital Project needs. Other agencies represented at this hearing included the Buffalo Museum of Science, the Buffalo Zoo, Kleinhans Music Hall, and Shea's Performing Arts Center. The capital repair needs of all these facilities are significant. Unfortunately, the City's difficult financial position leaves little funding available to meet these needs. The Comptroller has indicated that the City's debt limit would only allow up to $22,500,000 to be borrowed for capital projects in 2003. The City currently has a backlog of $30,725,000 for projects authorized in previous budget years, but not yet funded, which substantially exceeds the amount of debt that can be issued. Therefore, the Mayor recommended no funding for 2003 projects. The Mayor's recommendations do include $25,000 for library improvements at Crane, North Park, and Fairfield, which was authorized in the 2000-2001 budget year. The committee's recommendations will be issued later this fall and forwarded to the Common Council for consideration. Summer Programs Keep Kids Active and Engaged: A variety of programs entertained and educated children of all ages at public libraries throughout Erie County this summer. Summer Cyber Camp attracted a total of 525 students at sessions conducted in 37 of the system's branch and contract libraries. Hit the Books, the summer reading program sponsored by the Buffalo Bills and UPS, was a huge success with 4,858 students in Erie County reading 11,480 books. In its fourth year, Battle of the Books was bigger and better than ever. 393 children participated - 39 teams representing Central, city and contract libraries. More than 175 volunteers contributed their time and expertise to help the teams prepare and compete in this annual program sponsored by the Library Foundation of Buffalo & Erie County, Inc. Live Homework Help Arrives: As part of Summer Cyber Camp, instructors introduced this new online homework service. A grant from the Library Foundation is funding a pilot program that will continue through January 2003. Students who visit the Central Library or who have remote access from home or school can connect with an online tutor daily from 2 p.m. to 10 p.m. Beginning September 23rd, the East Delavan Branch and the Reinstein Memorial Library (Cheektowaga) will be added as test sites. At the conclusion of the pilot study, the service may be extended to all B&ECPL locations, depending on staff/customer evaluation and available funding. Executive Leadership Institute: During the first week in September, Assistant Deputy Directors Ruth Collins and Mary Jean Jakubowski and Doreen Woods, Process Improvement Study Coordinator, participated in the first of three Executive Leadership Institute meetings sponsored by the Urban Libraries Council. This was the initial opportunity for participants to discuss projects with peers and meet with their assigned coach. The B&ECPL team will focus on redefining and re-energizing the Library's mobile library operations. Catherine Fitzgerald of Fitzgerald Counseling has been assigned to the coach position. Ms. Fitzgerald, a psychologist, is familiar with the B&ECPL as she completed her graduate studies at the University of Buffalo. The sessions featured various activities designed to promote action learning, enhance listening skills, and develop an understanding of the challenges and promises facing leaders of today. Strategies regarding media image, political savvy, and networking were introduced. The team returned energized and ready to begin work on its assignment. Jefferson Construction Project: Watts Engineering has replaced Robson & Woese Inc. as the electrical/mechanical engineering subcontractor on the project. Deputy Directors Mahaney and Whelan and Service Evaluation and Planning Coordinator Peggy Skotnicki have met with representatives from Watts on several occasions to discuss the relocation of the mechanical rooms and to review voice, data and power requirements for the new building. The City plans to bid the project this fall. Project LIFT Concludes on High Note: On August 24th, Terrie Williams, CEO of the Terrie Williams Agency and co-founder of the Stay Strong Foundation, presented "The Stay Strong Experience with Terrie Williams and Friends" as the culminating event for the Library Involvement For Teens (LIFT) Project. Approximately 85 teens and adults attended and responded positively to the program in the Central Library's Mason O. Damon Auditorium. Books, posters, CDs and gift certificates were presented as prizes. Ms. Williams is also the author of Stay Strong: Simple Life Lessons for Teens. Everybody Into the Pool: In May 2000, the Support Services Department introduced an improved process designed to provide faster delivery of new material to those on waiting lists. Whenever the number of outstanding requests for a title meets or exceeds the number of copies purchased, the material is assigned automatically to the "Book Pool" and is sent directly from the Central Library's Processing Department (bypassing an unnecessary trip to a local library) to fill requests. This procedure works quite well; however, many titles do not meet "Bookpool" criteria and are not getting to the patron as quickly as they might until now. Based on the success of "Book Pool," Support Services Manager Ann Kling has devised an improved process dubbed "Waiting Pool," which she unveiled at the September 18th Managers Meeting. Whenever the number of outstanding requests for a title - now both print and non-print - equals at least 50% of the number of copies ordered, the Processing Department fills the requests directly with as many copies as needed. As with "Book Pool," "Waiting Pool" copies will be sent directly to those on the waiting list. Copies not needed to fill requests, will be delivered to the purchasing library and will be available immediately for browsers. Unlike "Book Pool," copies in the "Waiting Pool" appear in the online catalog as assigned to a particular library from the moment they are inventoried. The benefits of this project are numerous. Requested material gets into the hands of borrowers faster; holdings of individual libraries are displayed more understandably in the catalog; materials do not need to be shipped back and forth between Central and local libraries before they reach the patrons who request them; media requests (both audio and video) can be managed in the same manner as book requests, and the Processing Department will not need to handle items multiple times. Rare Book Cataloging Project Update: On June 24th, the fourth and final member of the cataloging team joined the project. After a short training period, this cataloger is up to speed and is making a substantial contribution. Since the beginning of this project (funded by the Library Foundation from a grant from the John R. Oishei Foundation) a total of 3,482 bibliographic records and 8,403 item records have been added to the catalog. In the last quarter, several unusual items were cataloged. These include an edition of Cicero's writing on rhetoric (published in the sixteenth century) and a miniature edition of Rules of the Franciscan Order, published in Seville in 1660. An elaborate edition of the Haggadah, a liturgical text for Passover, has been cataloged. This beautiful volume is printed on vellum, in both Hebrew and English and is illustrated in color. Reflecting the generosity of the community to the Library, this item was donated by 29 families and businesses, whose names are included. A collection of bookplates and other ephemera, which had been compiled and individually mounted by Thomas D. Mahoney, has been cataloged. Among the famous names represented in the collection are Queen Elizabeth II, Louis XIV and Millard Fillmore. Complementing B&ECPL's diverse holdings of Mark Twain's Adventures of Huckleberry Finn are new records for translations in German, Hungarian, Lithuanian, Bulgarian and Chinese, as well as a three-volume edition in Braille. Process Improvement Project: The pilot project was successful and, based on its results, the survey instrument has been refined. Tony Fischetti of New York Public Library is improving the Excel data entry tool and building the Access database. B&ECPL staff recently visited the Bulger Communications Center at Buffalo State College to produce an instructional video to present during site visits to each library. This will provide staff members, who cannot attend the meeting at their location, with consistent information necessary to complete the work distribution chart. Thanks go to the media experts at Buffalo State College and to B&ECPL staff Doreen Woods, Peggy Skotnicki, Meg Cheman, Ami Savigny and Michael Mahaney for their on-camera participation and to librarian Kathy Smith (East Clinton Branch) for her work behind the camera. In addition to her on-screen presence, Mrs. Woods developed the script and served as producer of this 18-minute visual teaching aid. On the Road: On August 31st, the Lookie Bookie participated in the 11th annual Unity Day in Sperry Park, sponsored by the 31 Alumni Association, a local Ellicott District Volunteer Group. Urban Services staff members read stories and distributed library bookmarks and publicity to many children and adults who attended the event. On September 10th, the RAM Van visited the Stanley Makowski Early Childhood Center for the first day of school. Parents enjoyed visiting the vehicle and seeing what it offers as they picked up and dropped off their children. This special visit was arranged through EPIC and the Makowski Center. B&ECPL Staff Attend Black Caucus: From August 13th to 16th, Sharon Holley, Coordinator of Urban Services, Sandra Williams Bush (North Jefferson Branch) and Gwen Collier (Urban Services) represented the B&ECPL at the 5th National Conference of Black Librarians at the Black Caucus of the American Library Association in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Workshop Assists Grant Seekers: On September 17th, the Central Library (in cooperation with the New York-based Foundation Center) is hosting a workshop to highlight the extensive resources available in the Business, Science and Technology Department. Erika Wittlieb, from the Foundation Center, will conduct the workshop for representatives of non-profit organizations seeking fundraising information. Public response has been overwhelming. Registrations had to be capped at 75! Service Evaluation & Planning Committee: All libraries/public service departments are completing a survey developed by the Outreach Committee to evaluate services for senior and disabled populations. In September, the Business Services Committee will present four training sessions on the basic business resources that have been provided to all libraries in the System. Landscape Improvements: Head Gardener Tim Tuminno has completed landscaping projects at the Mead and Niagara Branches. The Mead project was supported by donations from the community and the Niagara Branch improvements were made possible by an allocation from County Legislator Albert DeBenedetti. Next, attention will shift to North Park and Riverside, which also received funding support from Legislator DeBenedetti. Meetings: On September 10th, the Library's Foundation Review Committee and the Foundation's Select Committee voted to merge and form the Projects Review Committee, which will be responsible for the review of projects proposed by Library staff for Foundation funding. Under the leadership of Chair Wayne Wisbaum, the new committee then considered the Central Library Renovation Project and agreed to request that the Foundation undertake a $1,000,000 fund-raising initiative for the project. Agenda Item G - Report of the Foundation Director. In addition to her written report which contained information regarding a grant from Praxair, a bequest from the Estate of Kelvin H. Ferber, a royalty supplement from "A Murder, a Mystery, and a Marriage," an update on the Nelson Mandela Folktales project and other B&ECPL funding support, Ms. Vedder endorsed the comments about the Central Library renovation project and said she expects the Foundation Board will support it as well on September 24th. The Fall Grosvenor Concert series commences on September 25th with a MusicalFare production. In response to Ms. Mahoney's comment regarding an article which appeared in a recent edition of the Buffalo News on "Live Homework Help," Assistant Deputy Director Ami Savigny indicated she will be meeting with the Buffalo Alliance for Education to discuss ways to disseminate information to area schools. Agenda Item H - Public Comment. No public comment. Agenda Item I - Unfinished Business. No unfinished business. Agenda Item J. New Business. Agenda Item J.1 - Reappointment of Deputy Director Kenneth H. Stone. Ms. Chrisman recommended the reappointment of Kenneth H. Stone to a 3-year term as Deputy Director, Chief Financial Officer. Mr. Burns heartily endorsed the recommendation and noted that Mr. Stone "makes a troublesome task sensible and gets the job done in top grade fashion." On motion by Mr. Burns and seconded by Ms. Summer, the following was approved unanimously: RESOLUTION 2002-59
Agenda Item J.2 - LSTA Summer Reading Program Grant. Assistant Deputy Director Ruth Collins informed Trustees that under the Library Services and Technology Act, the Division of Library Development awards a grant to the library system that takes on the responsibility for planning the Summer Reading Program for all New York State libraries. Children's services specialists at the recipient library system develop the theme (appropriate for children aged pre-school to teens) for the program and supporting ideas for creative presentations of literature, crafts and other components of children's programming that can be adapted throughout the state. The grant subsidizes the costs associated with hiring a copy editor and graphic artist to assist staff in production of materials to support the program. This $36,000 grant relates to the Summer Reading Program for 2004. On motion by Ms. Juncewicz and seconded by Ms. Summer, the following was approved unanimously: RESOLUTION 2002-60
Ms. Summer invited trustees to attend the October 7th Bistro Bookers program, which features discussion of the book, "No Free Lunch: One Man's Journey From Welfare to the American Dream," written by her nephew Gary Karton and Rodney Carroll. There being no further business, on motion by Ms. Mahoney and seconded by Dr. Raoof, the meeting was adjourned at approximately 4:30 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Annette A. Juncewicz |
Buffalo & Erie County Public Library * 1 Lafayette Square * Buffalo, NY 14203
* (716) 858-8900 * Fax: (716) 858-6211
Do you have a question for our Library staff? Use AskUs.
Do you have a comment about this website? Use Feedback.